Who decides what is logical in a travel policy?
Two buyers call the lowest logical fare outdated. A convention in Dallas and a race weekend in São Paulo show where it stops.
You are going to tell me that the lowest logical fare is the most sensible rule in the book, and I am going to agree with you for about three paragraphs. It is simple. It is fair. It gives finance a number, it gives the traveler a rule, and it spares everyone the weekly argument about whether a flight at 6 a.m. on the cheapest carrier is really worth the 40 dollars saved. For years it won that argument, and it won it honestly.
Then a Grand Prix weekend arrives in São Paulo, and the hotel network is almost full, and a rule that says “book 15 days ahead and take the cheapest option” meets a city that does not care what the rule says. I wrote about that effect on rates in my piece on the São Paulo Grand Prix, where aggregated and anonymized booking data processed by the VOLL platform showed corporate hotel rates rising by up to 38% on race nights. The rule held up on paper, and the calendar of race weekend simply never entered it.
That is the question I want to take apart today. The lowest logical fare has served programs well. My concern sits with the word “logical”, because someone has to decide what counts as logical, and that someone is usually a column in a spreadsheet.
The policy that won the argument
For readers who have never had to enforce it, a lowest logical fare policy asks a traveler to book the cheapest option that makes sense within a reasonable window of the intended time. “Reasonable” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. A flight three hours earlier might count. A flight the next day usually does not. The traveler is allowed to be sensible, and the company is allowed to stop paying for sloppiness.
I understand why it spread. A single clear parameter turns a negotiation into a check box, and for a travel manager running a program with limited staff, that is a gift. A simple rule is easier to follow, easier to audit and easier to defend to a CFO, and those advantages have not gone away.
What has changed is the traveler, and what has changed with the traveler is the evidence. In an October town hall summarized by Business Travel Executive, two travel program leaders who report into procurement, Katie Williams and Kathy Burdge, took on exactly this rule. Williams said the lowest logical fare policies “are a bit outdated now because of how travelers are choosing to travel”. Burdge, who prefers a “price to beat” approach, noted that it also falls short when it ignores what loyalty programs actually deliver. Two people who run global programs and who sit on the buying side of the table reached the same conclusion without my help, which I find more persuasive than anything I could say.
A column of prices cannot hold the whole cost
The first problem with a fare comparison is that a fare is the part of a trip that fits in a column. The rest of the cost does not.
The same discussion listed what tends to stay outside the policy: extra fees that accumulate, forced connections that wear a traveler down, and the benefits that come with loyalty status, such as baggage, priority boarding and lounge access, which can protect a traveler’s productivity. These items rarely appear in the rule, and Williams acknowledged that her company does not quantify them today. I appreciated the candor. Most programs do not, and the ones that say so are the ones that have a chance of fixing it.
I would add a few costs from my own experience in São Paulo, because they are the ones I feel. Time stopped on the Marginal Pinheiros, where a trip by taxi or ride-hailing app can take more than an hour. The time it takes to get off the plane and out of Guarulhos, a large terminal where distance is part of the journey. The wait for a car at Congonhas on a Monday morning or a Sunday night, when many travelers in the city want a car at the same moment. Every one of these is a cost. Almost none of them is in the policy. I explored this idea in my piece on the hidden cost nobody puts on the expense report, where the largest item turned out to be time, paid for in salaries and never in tickets.
It would be unfair to say a fare rule cannot see any of this. It can, but only if someone puts these items into the rule, and that takes a different way of thinking about what “cheapest” means.
Dallas, 2023, and the map that lied by omission
I learned my own version of this lesson at my first GBTA convention, in Dallas in 2023, and I learned it with money.
I chose an Airbnb. The map said it was close to the convention center, and in distance it was. The map did not show the traffic at rush hour, which turned a short distance into a long ride, repeated morning and evening, for the days of the event. By the end of the week, I had spent more on taxis and rides than a hotel one block from the convention center would have cost for the nights. My apartment was cheaper per night, and my trip was more expensive. Both of those statements were true at the same time, and only one of them appeared on the booking screen.
I find that experience useful because I did not choose carelessly. I used the criteria that looked objective, such as the nightly rate and the distance on the map. Applied on their own, objective criteria are insufficient. They gave me a precise answer to the wrong question.
The cheapest bed is not always the cheapest night
The following years taught me to ask a better question. In Atlanta, in Denver and in Chicago, I started to compare the total cost of the stay: the nightly rate, whether breakfast was included, whether the internet was free or paid, and what it would cost to get to the place where I actually needed to be. On trips of two to four days, and more so on longer ones, that comparison often reversed the order of the options. The hotel that looked expensive in a list looked reasonable once the whole picture was visible.
Those years also taught me something about the traveler on the other side of the booking. A good bed, a spacious room, reliable internet and a night of real sleep make an executive more productive the next day. Companies make the same case when they buy good equipment for their engineers. I have the impression that many travel managers have grown a great deal in this respect.
When I sit with them today, I see a much more mature reading of what a trip costs and what it produces, and a growing comfort with the idea that the lowest number is where the analysis begins.
I have written about why hotels are where corporate travel really happens, and this is a large part of the reason. The room is where the trip is won or lost, and a policy that treats it as an afterthought is leaving value on the table.
When the calendar sets the price
So what would a better rule look like? I think it starts with the recognition that a parameter should depend on circumstance and expire with it.
Consider a few cases that I am imagining for the sake of the argument, and that do not describe any client or any real policy. A company has a rule that asks travelers to book 15 days ahead. In an ordinary week, that is a reasonable target. In a week when a large medical congress fills 90% of a city’s hotel network, 15 days is not enough, and the rule quietly pushes people into the most expensive rooms on the market or into a hotel too far from the meeting. Now imagine a smarter version: book 15 days ahead, unless the nightly rate is between 20% and 30% above the average, in which case the traveler should book earlier or choose another neighborhood. That rule knows something about the world.
Or take the Grand Prix again, with nearly the whole network sold out, and imagine a company that decides travelers should book months before the race. Or take a festival such as Rock in Rio, where a sensible advance for people who must be in the city might be closer to 200 days than to 15. In each case, the lesson is the same. The calendar of the destination belongs in the policy.
I made a similar argument about daily allowances when I looked at what the IRS per diem map can teach a Latin American travel policy. A rule that is simple enough to apply everywhere will fit nowhere perfectly. The craft lies in choosing a small number of well-chosen levels and revisiting them with fresh data, which is a different thing from adding a rule for every case.
What the cheapest price to beat still misses
Burdge’s preferred alternative deserves a closer look, because many programs have moved in that direction. A “price to beat” approach asks the traveler to compare options against a benchmark price, which is more flexible than a single cheapest-fare rule. Yet it carries the same blind spot, as she pointed out in the same discussion: it can ignore the benefits that come with loyalty programs.
A traveler who flies one airline regularly, and who earns bag fees waived, priority boarding and lounge access in return, may be buying a better trip for slightly more money. A benchmark that sees only the fare treats that traveler as a rule-breaker.
I find this the most interesting part of the discussion, because it shows that the problem is bigger than the lowest logical fare. Any rule that counts a single number will eventually collide with a traveler who is optimizing for something else. The fix is a wider definition of value, and that takes agreement between travel, finance and procurement about what the company is buying when it buys a trip.
Stricter enforcement of a blind rule
There is another detail in the discussion that I keep returning to, and it is more relevant now that airfares are climbing. One of the two programs responded to rising costs by tightening its policy. The other kept its policy but became more strict about enforcing it. Both reactions are understandable. When costs go up, a company wants control, and the quickest form of control is to hold the line harder.
The risk is that stricter enforcement of a context-blind rule increases friction without increasing savings. The traveler who was already following the rule has to justify exceptions more often. The traveler who faced a real constraint, such as a sold-out city, a forced connection or an event week, meets a rule that cannot hear the explanation. I am not criticizing either company, because I do not know the details of their programs. I am pointing at a pattern that I have seen in different markets: when a rule is not working, the first instinct is to apply it harder. A better instinct is to ask what the rule is missing.
The moment of booking is the only moment that counts
The buyers also raised a practical point about where information should live. One of them wants relevant messages, such as preferred suppliers and promotions, to appear inside the booking flow, since travelers tend to dismiss banners and pop-ups after seeing them once. I agree, and I would extend it to the policy itself. In the piece I wrote on time as the hidden cost, the same idea appeared in a different form: a policy that lives in a PDF nobody reads cannot help anyone, while a policy check that happens at the moment of booking can.
If a circumstance belongs in the rule, it also belongs on the screen where the traveler decides. A message that says “this is a race weekend and the hotel network is tight, so book earlier or consider another neighborhood” is worth more than a paragraph in a handbook. The traveler is the person who can act, and the moment of booking is the only moment when acting is cheap. After the ticket is issued, every correction costs time, money or both.
Where I sit
I should say where I sit, because it shapes how I read this subject. I am a co-founder of VOLL, a corporate travel platform, and our product has to answer this very question every day: how do you turn a policy into something a traveler can follow at the moment of booking?
Event weeks are the case I think about most, since the effect I measured around the Grand Prix repeats around every large event in the region. One thing we have started to do is let a travel manager describe a policy in a conversation, in plain words, instead of building it field by field. I mention it here only as a hint of where the problem is heading.
If a policy can be written the way a person would explain it to a colleague, then adding a circumstance to it becomes as easy as adding a sentence.
A rule such as “book the cheapest reasonable option, but for event weeks, book earlier and stay within walking distance of the venue” is easy to say and hard to configure in a form. The technology exists to narrow that gap, and that is what interests me.
Is the lowest logical fare finished?
A fair word of caution belongs here. Changing a policy takes longer than writing it. The buyers noted that budget, staffing and integrating new suppliers are the usual obstacles, and that security and legal due diligence can take six months or more. That is a useful reminder for anyone tempted to fix this in a quarter. The circumstances can be added gradually, one at a time, starting with the ones that cause the most pain.
No, and I would not want to see it disappear. A default is valuable. Most trips, in most weeks, in most cities, are served well by a clear and simple rule. What I would change is what the rule is allowed to know.
The buyers in that October discussion offered several suggestions that fit this view. They want a tool that shows, at the moment of decision, what a trip like this one typically costs, so the traveler sees the whole picture, beyond the fare in front of them. They want better ways to handle unused credits without calling an agent. And Williams, whose company is mid-sized but global, made a point I liked: she wants to be the first call when a supplier is looking for a partner to pilot something new. That is a good reminder that improvement comes from buyers and suppliers working on the problem together.
There is one more reason I would write the circumstance into the policy instead of leaving it to the traveler’s judgment. A traveler who faces a sold-out city without guidance has to improvise, and improvising under time pressure is when people make expensive choices.
A policy that names the circumstance gives the traveler permission to do the sensible thing and gives the finance team a record of why. That record also makes the next policy review easier, because the exceptions stop looking like violations and start looking like data.
Loyalty deserves its own thought. For years, the traveler collected the benefits while the company paid the fare, and it was an awkward arrangement that nobody enjoyed discussing. I looked at what changes when software starts making the booking decision in my article on loyalty programs and AI, and I think the same shift will make policies look at the whole value of a trip rather than only its price.
Two more observations before I stop. The first is that the cheapest option often turns out to be the most expensive one when you finish counting. The second is that a policy is an expression of what a company values. A policy that counts only the fare tells travelers that fares are all the company sees. A policy that counts time, rest and circumstance tells them the company sees the trip.
I started by granting that the lowest logical fare is common sense. I still think so. But common sense depends on who is looking, and when, and from where. So I will end with a question that I would like you to answer in the comments or in your next policy review.
If your policy could learn one more sentence tomorrow, which circumstance would you teach it first?
About me
I am an entrepreneur with over 20 years of experience at the intersection of tourism and technology. I am co-founder and Chief Business Officer of VOLL, the largest mobile-first corporate travel and expense management platform in Latin America, where I lead the commercial strategy behind our AI adoption.
A first-cohort graduate of The AI-Powered Organization at Stanford Graduate School of Business and a Marketing specialist from Fundação Dom Cabral, I serve on the Tourism Council of FecomércioSP and on the Executive Council of the Latin American Association of Corporate Events and Travel Management (Alagev). I write and speak about innovation, digital transformation, entrepreneurial leadership, and the future of corporate travel.




Discussion about this post